Wednesday's Slate: Three Home Run Angles Built on Platoon Edge and Recent Pitcher Collapse
By Justin Erickson ·
A full 16-game card with three matchups featuring hitters who hold measurable platoon advantages against struggling right-handed starters.
Wednesday's 16-game MLB slate opens with a Cubs-Mets doubleheader and spreads betting action across the afternoon and evening windows. Within that volume sits a trio of home run angles all stemming from the same structural advantage: left-handed hitters facing right-handed starters who've hemorrhaged home runs to opposite-handed batters in recent weeks.
Luis Garcia Jr. of the Nationals leads the shortlist. He carries the platoon advantage against Phillies starter Aaron Nola, a right-hander who has ceded nine of his 15 home runs this season to lefties. More pressingly, Nola has allowed 10 earned runs across 14 innings over his last three outings—including four home runs. Garcia himself has hit three long balls in his last 10 home games and owns a 13-for-41 career record against Nola with two of those hits leaving the yard. The platoon setup is clean; the pitcher's recent volatility compounds the edge.
Spencer Steer of the Reds presents a similar but slightly different case. He sits at .310 with a 1.069 OPS against left-handed pitchers this season—elite footing from the right side of the plate. Brewers starter Shane Drohan has allowed all four of his home runs to right-handed batters, a small sample but a directional signal. Steer has also pushed three home runs across his last 10 home games. The platoon split is narrower than Garcia's situation (fewer home runs conceded by Drohan overall), but Steer's recent power volume at home strengthens the case.
Caleb Durbin of the Red Sox rounds out the trio as the volatility play. He's a relative unknown quantity—his season average sits at .220—but he's lifted that mark from .192 over the last week and has homered three times in his last 10 road games. The real propellant here is Rockies starter Kyle Freeland's fragility: he's given up 13 of his 14 home runs to right-handers, who are batting .323 with a .946 OPS against him. Freeland has imploded recently, allowing 11 earned runs in 18 innings across his last three starts. For a +880 underdog play, the underlying pitch-selection and batted-ball risk tilts heavily in Durbin's direction.
The common thread across all three: pitcher injury or fatigue expressed through home run rate. Nola and Freeland have both surrendered elevated run totals and multiple home runs in their recent work. That's not randomness—that's mechanical or velocity-based decline. Garcia's platoon edge becomes lethal when paired with a starter leaking fastballs. Steer's recent home-game power and Drohan's narrow home-run concession history make for a tighter but stillPlayable spot. Durbin's case hinges entirely on Freeland's recent unraveling; if Freeland rebounds to form, the prop evaporates. Each angle survives because it's rooted in observable pitcher deterioration, not one-off hot streaks.